In recent days, the local press has published a series of interviews with hydraulic engineering professors from the University of Padua, who recently released a scientific paper in the well-regarded journal Nature Water (doi.org/10.1038/s44221-026-00658-1). The study compares the MOSE floodgate operations carried out between 2020 and 2023 with simulated operations for the same high-water events, based on an alternative strategy designed to maximize the periods during which the lagoon’s salt marshes remain submerged, while still keeping the lagoon’s water level below the 110-centimeter ceiling. The research offers a welcome opportunity to refocus attention on the lagoon’s salt-marsh habitats, which have been suffering badly from a shortage of sediment inflow from the rivers of the drainage basin and from the halt in maintenance and reconstruction work.
The interviews raised the possibility of reducing both the number and duration of MOSE barrier closures — with beneficial effects for the marshes and for port operations — by adopting a closure strategy different from the one actually in use.
The two strategies, however, are not fully comparable, for the following reasons:
The operations actually carried out:
were designed to prevent the flooding of urban land sitting 110 centimeters above the Punta della Salute tide-gauge datum (LMPS) — a stricter benchmark than the one used by the Padua modelers, who simply held the lagoon’s level under the 110-centimeter LMPS ceiling. The real-world target accounts for the fact that the lagoon’s surface is never perfectly flat: it is roughened by waves and distorted by wind. Wind- and boat-wake-generated waves of 10 centimeters or more can crest over the banks and flood the land, meaning the water level actually has to be held to 95–100 centimeters LMPS.
had to account for forecasting uncertainty — particularly in weather forecasts for wind and rain, and in runoff from the drainage basin — uncertainty that forces the barriers to close well before the tide reaches its assigned limits, and at lower thresholds, and therefore for longer stretches of time. Wind, as is well known, can produce sudden level differences of more than 20 centimeters between the southern and northern ends of the lagoon, a factor that cannot be ignored.
The operations simulated using the University of Padua’s model:
pursued a less demanding objective than the one actually in force — simply staying under 110 centimeters LMPS — without accounting for wind- and wake-driven waves, a factor that the real operations did have to manage.
were built on historical data without incorporating the safety margins needed to offset the inherent uncertainty of forecasting.
The paper also revisits the question of insufficient marsh submersion resulting from the way MOSE closures blunt exceptional high-water events. Such closures, the authors argue, reduce sediment delivery — both because less turbid water reaches the marshes and because it remains there for less time (at a given sediment concentration, the volume of deposited sediment depends on the volume of water involved). This reduction, in turn, would help explain why the marshes are failing to offset the loss of surface elevation caused by natural compaction and subsidence of the underlying soil.
This phenomenon has already been examined through numerical modeling in earlier scientific papers by the research group at the University of Padua’s Department of Geosciences.
A few observations follow:
Refining MOSE’s closure strategies is both possible and worthwhile — and, in fact, it is already happening. The protocols currently used by the MOSE control center differ from those in place in 2023 and are continually being fine-tuned, thanks to improvements in forecasting systems and to field trials aimed at minimizing the time the port’s four inlets remain closed, including through non-synchronized closures across the inlets. Continued refinement of, and debate over, closure protocols remains essential.
Adopting the strategy proposed in the study could yield real reductions in closures — but, regrettably, far smaller ones than the interviews suggested.
Whatever protection such measures could offer the marsh habitats — a claim that should be verified with field monitoring alongside the mathematical simulations — would not, on its own, be enough to guarantee their survival. That problem remains open and will require targeted, adequate interventions of its own.
Meanwhile, closures of the barriers at the inlets continue to grow in both number and duration: climate change marches on, and it shows no mercy.
A meaningful reduction in closures will only be possible once the planned supplementary measures to MOSE are completed — defenses for the edges of the historic city’s low-lying “macroinsulae” districts at 120–130 centimeters LMPS. These measures were first designed in the late 1990s and then shelved so resources could be concentrated on finishing the MOSE system itself.
Now that MOSE is operational — and now that we know it will not remain effective forever — it is time to get back to work, resuming the design studies and trials that were set aside.
L’articolo MOSE and the Salt Marshes proviene da ytali..